GROUPON PR MISSTEPS

Groupon Inc. has been the darling of social media until yesterday. The company produced its first Super Bowl ads and unfortunately they missed the mark and have been labeled offensive by members of the viewing public. (For those unsure of what Groupon is-the company blends groups and coupons and provides discounted rates on local services. It’s a new platform that has taken the industry by storm and has changed the game for online retail discounts.)

Groupon Faced a PR Crisis with its Tibet Super Bowl Ad

This is a newish company (started in 2008) with a youngish founder Andrew Mason and as such, hiccups like this one are not uncommon. Therefore, due to the backlash from their Tibet themed Super Bowl ad, Mason’s PR reps issued a statement regarding the situation.  As a PR practitioner, I thought this would be a great case study for crisis communication and how important it is to have professionals handle these matters in a timely fashion.

PR CASE IN POINT

Below is the complete statement (apology from Andrew Mason) that was posted on the Groublogon blog.  Needless to say, I was not impressed.  Groupon did not take the high-road. In fact, they did some finger pointing which is always a bad practice. The best way to hit a crisis like this is head on and own up to your mistakes. I would have advised a different take on the tone and length.  To see my recommendations look for my comments and thoughts in orange. I also rewrote the statement and that is included at the end of the post.

Andrew Mason’s Comments Regarding Groupon’s Super Bowl Ads

I’ve been spending the day listening to the negative feedback about our Tibet Super Bowl commercial, and want to take a crack at explaining why we created this campaign. (Crack was a poor choice of words.  He should have been more confident and stand behind his beliefs as opposed to taking a stab at explaining his campaign. Therefore, a much stronger opening sentence would have been…and want to explain why we created the campaign. Also, since he’s a tech guy, he should have made this statement into a video post. That way we could have seen that he was really behind it. That he stands by his words.)

We take the causes we highlighted extremely seriously – that’s why we created this campaign in partnership with many hallmark community organizations, for whom we’re raising money at SaveTheMoney.org. Groupon’s roots are in social activism – we actually began as cause-based website called The Point, and we continue to use Groupon to support local causes with our G-Team initiative. In our two short years as a business, we’ve already raised millions of dollars for national charities like Donors Choose and Kiva. (Good paragraph explaining their stance on causes. Having this paragraph appear as the second graph was wrong placement. It should be lower in the body.  By placing this so high up, he comes off defensive.)

When we think about commercials that offend us, we think of those that glorify antisocial behavior – like the scores of Super Bowl ads that are built around the crass objectification of women. Unlike those ads, no one walks away from our commercials taking the causes we highlighted less seriously. Not a single person watched our ad and concluded that it’s cool to kill whales. In fact – and this is part of the reason we ran them – they have the opposite effect. (This is the biggest error in the statement. The finger needs to pointed at Groupon not others. You’re guilty, own up to it. I’d delete the entire thing.)

The firm that conceived the ad, Crispin Porter & Bogusky, strives to draw attention to the cultural tensions created by brands. When they created this Hulu ad, they highlighted the idea that TV rots your brain, making fun of Hulu. Our ads highlight the often trivial nature of stuff on Groupon when juxtaposed against bigger world issues, making fun of Groupon. Why make fun of ourselves? Because it’s different – ads are traditionally about shameless self promotion, and we’ve always strived to have a more honest and respectful conversation with our customers. We would never have run these ads if we thought they trivialized the causes – even if we didn’t take them as seriously as we do, what type of company would go out of their way to be so antagonistic? (Again, no reason to hang the firm out to dry. Groupon approved the concept and the ad. Groupon is the guilty party. I say loose this paragraph entirely. Take the high road Andrew! Also, all this name dropping isn’t a good business practice. No need to bring Hulu into this situation. Also if I was the firm I wouldn’t have allowed by name to be used in this way. I think that firm needs to put out their own statement saying that they followed their client’s wishes.)

We took this approach knowing that, if anything, they would bring more funding and support to the highlighted causes. That’s why organizations like Greenpeace, buildOn, The Tibet Fund, and the Rainforest Action Network all decided to throw their support behind the campaign (read Greenpeace’s blog post here). In fact, the feedback led us to make changes to the end of our ads that further encourage our fundraising. To that point, if the ads affected you, we hope you’ll head over to SaveTheMoney.org and make a donation (which we’ll match) – we’re hoping to raise a lot of money. (Good points, however, poorly executed. Andrew is still defending his campaign. He needs to let it go and just apologize.)

The last thing we wanted was to offend our customers – it’s bad business and it’s not where our hearts are. (Best line of the statement. Should be at the start.)

RONZONI’S RE-WRITE

Here’s what I would have recommended as a statement. Less is always best.

I’ve been spending the day listening to feedback about our Tibet Super Bowl commercial and want to explain the campaign. The last thing we wanted was to offend our customers and Super Bowl viewers – it’s bad business and it’s not where our hearts are nor is it our company’s philosophy.

We take the causes extremely seriously – that’s why we created this campaign in partnership with many hallmark community organizations, for whom we’re raising money at SaveTheMoney.org. Groupon’s roots are in social activism – we actually began as cause-based website called The Point, and we continue to use Groupon to support local causes with our G-Team initiative. In our two short years as a business, we’ve already raised millions of dollars for national charities like Donors Choose and Kiva.

Our motive and intentions were pure, however, our creative approach fell short in highlighting the causes represented in the commercials. This was not our intent.

Thanks to the feedback we have received changes have been made to our ads that further encourage fundraising. To that point, we hope you’ll head over to SaveTheMoney.org and make a donation which which we will gladly match. It’s the least we can do and we hope to raise a significant amount for these charities.

Thank you for understanding and we promise to do better in helping others.

Sincerely,

Andrew Mason

Founder and CEO, Groupon

What are your thoughts regarding Groupon’s non-apology. Do you agree with a defensive PR approach?

For those of you who missed the commercial…here you go.

Tibet Groupon Commercial

PR Campaign Series – Part 1 – Walgreens Wellness Tour

A Community Serving - Not Self Serving Campaign

If I could be in charge of the marketing campaigns for major brands, the National Urban League and Walgreens Wellness Tour is an exact example of how I would invest my money. It is worth every penny spent.

I have worked on dozens of marketing campaigns in my career from giving away a replica of “The Simpsons” house to winning a date with a “90210″ star to attending a Super Bowl.  I have also been privileged to work on anti-drug messaging campaigns, Toys 4 Tots and feeding the homeless initiatives.  My favorite, in my humble opinion, have always been the ones that served others and not necessary solely served the company -(i.e., like winning tickets to a screening or a free Flip camera.)

Last week, I literally stumbled over a campaign that just warmed my heart and one that I needed to recognize as a job well done.  It’s the National Urban League and Walgreens Wellness Tour. I love this campaign and applaud this partnership. Why?

A WELL RUN CAMPAIGN

This mobile medical (pictured) unit is crisscrossing the country providing FREE Health Screenings. In a matter of a six minute span you can literally have you cholesterol, blood glucose, blood pressure , body mass index and bone density checked.  The process was easy, user-friendly, not scary and efficient.

How do I know? Well, I had to stop by and test it out. I wanted to see first-hand how this campaign was run for I’ve been involved in such community outreach projects in the past and some just aren’t all that they are cracked up to be. But, this one is and then some.

MAKING A DIFFERENCE

When large corporations invest in local community events I know its a rather big decision for regional events are very expensive, time consuming and labor intensive.  For Walgreens and the National Urban League to commit to this mobile medical unit, they both were committed to a large sum of money for a long period of time.  I am not sure how many mobile units are out in the field, but these units were outfitted with state of the art equipment and staff. This is a very expensive investment on paper and one that will take years to see a return of investment.  And I think that’s why I like it so much.

Would you rather save a life or giveaway and iPad?

Even though many of the people who receive a health screening through this effort may never return a Walgreens store or give to the National Urban League, this non-profit and national drug store didn’t care. They were more concerned with helping out others who cannot necessarily afford medical care.I am fortunate to be able to afford health care at this time, but I was in line with many people who cannot.  And that’s why this is such a great campaign.  For you see, after you have your tests completed you have to wait five minutes for your results.  As I waited I was able to observe others whose reports informed them that they were suffering from high cholesterol or blood pressure.  I’d say at least one-third of the people who went through the screening found out something that need further attention. How great is that! This campaign literally impacted the lives of others and in fact, is saving lives.

To me that’s money worth spent. And a much better campaign than spending three million dollars while advertising 30 seconds during the Super Bowl.

And, I normally shop at CVS just because of its proximity to my house.  But, if I have a choice I might frequent my Walgreens just to support them and their efforts in the community.

Bravo National Urban League and Walgreens.

Google Super Bowl Ad – Simplistic Brilliance

Did you happen to catch Google’s 60-second “Parisian Love” commercial during last Sunday’s  Super Bowl?

Google Scores A TouchDown during the Super Bowl

My guess is that you did for the annual football contest broke all television ratings records, delivering nearly 107 million viewers. This was an incredible feat in today’s day and age, because we have so much choice now for means of engagement.  But people tuned in and watched a heart-warming, closely-contested brilliantly played football game.  It was a pleasure to watch with terrific game plays and few penalties.

But today’s post isn’t about the game and its record ratings, but about the Google masterpiece.

At first blush, I tweeted that I thought this was a blah commercial…a no brainer for us that use it regularly.  But, after much thought, I was in awe of its simplicity and how well it described its true function. The commercial was on point and perfectly described what it did and then some.

For if you really think about it, how else would you describe Google other than its an amazing search engine.  It’s made to search and search everything.  Thus, this commercial was spot on.  Perfect.  It was true to its product and use.

It also is a great reminder to all of us who create messages whether its a press release, a promo, a viral video or a Yelp page.  Is the message clear?  Does the message depict the product?

A great example of a failure in this area is the Go Daddy commercials.  For those unfamiliar with its web products, you would have no idea what the product is.  It sells shock and awe and Google sells class.

So keep to the message. Stay on point. Be true to who you are and you will see it will pay off in droves.

Hats off to Google.

Also, did you get a whiff of what they are up to regarding social networking with Google Buzz.  You can learn more by watching this demo below.  I can hardly wait to start using it. I love gmail.

What did you think of the Google ad? Do you believe in a simple approach or a one that leaves you with a shocking message? I’d love to hear your thoughts.

Best,
Cindy